#p4480475,Deanira написал(а):#p4480463,Eterislouisvuitton написал(а):When she won her first national title at age 12, there were already reports of her suffering from serious injuries. This is not surprising.
Sport, in general, is a fickle thing. In 2024, Alisa didn't even step on the ice, and in 2025, everything changed. It's not Alisa's fault, but it's the truth: if Russian athletes hadn't had to choose a single contender a year before the Games, if the judges hadn't been so supportive, or if Adelia hadn't gotten injured, Alisa wouldn't have won gold. These are all just assumptions, but in any case, she's had a brilliant career—whether she returns or not. She's charismatic and fun. It's not her fault that things turned out the way they did—it's all down to external factors. Personally, I'd have preferred the Olympic gold to go to the skater who presented original programs, showed better skating, and jumps with full rotations.
The injury of Adelia and Alina was predictable, it wasn't a coincidence (I even talked about it here during the Olympic qualifying round). 17-18 is the age when Eteri's girls start losing quads and injuries start piling up. The skaters' injuries early this season are telling (if the previous examples weren't enough). This is the price to pay for a ton of quads and (relative) consistency at a young age.
And even if it were possible to send more than one, who do you think would win? Even if we forget about age and include Dvoeglazova—we saw how "well" she can skate at the Russian State Gymnastics Federation. Sadkova, Khusnutdinova, Akateva? That's not even funny. Okay, let's see what happens outside of the TShT. I like Muravyova, but she's also going through puberty and is unstable, so there's a high probability she'd make a mistake somewhere. Frolova probably could have won (with good support from the Federation), but then again, there's no guarantee. Zakharova's quads are like a lottery. Nelyubova might have had a chance with her triaxels, but that's not a given.
I don't understand where the takeaway comes from that Alisa won at the Olympics only in the absence of Russians. Logically, it doesn't work that way. Or would the entire reality have to change for that to happen?
Я понимаю вашу точку зрения. Я думал о Маше Захаровой, но, конечно, предугадать развитие событий невозможно. Случаются травмы, меняется форма — именно поэтому отбор на Олимпиаду обычно проводят за месяц до Игр, а не за год. Что было бы, если бы сборную США на Олимпиаду-2022 сформировали за год до соревнований? Напомню, что на чемпионате США Алиса занимала лишь четвертое место и переживала непростой период, хотя в итоге и сумела преодолеть трудности.
Даже с учетом всех обстоятельств, я считаю, что победа Сакамото была заслуженной. Оценка Алисы должна была быть ниже — даже с учетом допущенной ею ошибки. Я смотрел чемпионат мира 2025 года с трибун арены в Бостоне. Качество катания Алисы сильно отличается от уровня остальных девушек из топ-10. Дело не только в прыжках (хотя многие и делают недокруты): у нее нет ни хорошей осанки, ни утонченности, ни скорости, ни качественных связующих элементов. Это бросается в глаза — хуже нее каталась разве что Шизас. Она двигается небрежно, хаотично размахивая руками, и просто улыбается под веселую музыку. А ее положение тела в воздухе во время прыжка... Будь она повыше ростом, в полете она напоминала бы Грассля.
